One of these ideas, the sequential lineup (which shows the witness one lineup member at a time), increases the ratio of accurate to mistaken identifications compared with the traditional simultaneous lineup (which shows the witness all lineup members at … (The National Institute of Justice guide remarks, “Scientific research indicates that identification procedures such as lineups and photo arrays produce more reliable evidence when the individual lineup members or photographs are shown to the witness sequentially—one at a time—rather than simultaneously.”). By adopting the reforms recommended by the United States Department of Justice and following the lead of states such as North Carolina and Wisconsin, the Commonwealth of Kentucky can considerably reduce the number of innocent people it wrongfully imprisons. Most people are likely to agree that eyewitness misidentification is a bad thing – but many believe that it is not a common issue. This article begins by prior to conducting the identification procedure, the eyewitness must provide a description of the person suspected of committing the crime. Use of this feed is for personal non-commercial use only. Below is information on six of the most common causes and the role they have played in the cases of MAIP exonerations. investigations end earlier than they should. Eyewitness misidentification was involved in 72 percent of those cases. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole for rape. Abstract Eyewitness misidentification is one of the leading causes of wrongful conviction. Shouse Law Group has helped many citizens get charges reduced or dismissed, and keep their records clean. Witness Stress/Trauma: High stress levels drastically reduce the accuracy of eyewitness memory. Senate Bill 923 is a new California law. The criminal justice system puts a lot of faith in eyewitness testimony, but it actually is highly unreliable. First, when an eyewitness has initially misidentified a perpetrator of a crime, law enforcement officials become distracted, and lose precious time in pursuing the wrong person, rather than the true perpetrator. non-suspect “fillers” must be used in a lineup that match the eyewitness’ description of the suspect. suggestive or misleading police procedures. Eyewitness Misidentification. System Variables are factors related to the administration of live and photographic lineups and other identification procedures by law enforcement officials. Patterns in three decades of social science research indicate a variety of causes of eyewitness misidentification. Additionally, they should not place a suspect in the same position in multiple lineups. Research shows that the human mind is not like a tape recorder; we neither record events exactly as we see them, nor recall them like a tape that has been rewound. That is, when viewing a group of photos or individuals, a witness tends to select the person who looks "most like" the perpetrator. Eyewitness misidentification was a factor in 72 percent of these cases. The United States Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics, admits that statistically 8 to 12% of all state prisoners are either actually or factually innocent. Suggestive Identification. But while convictions based on eyewitness errors may be more frequent than are other types of erroneous convictions, in absolute terms they are rare. At the time the investigator prepares a lineup, whether it be in a 6-pack or otherwise, just knowing who the suspect is can be problematic. The Court system, although vague, has created some standards to help address the inaccuracies of eyewitness identification. At trial, she confidently identified Anthony as her daughter’s attacker, being so convincing that even Anthony believed he would be found guilty. In the United States, eyewitness misidentification was the leading cause of wrongful convictions in 72% of the first 318 wrongful convictions that were overturned by DNA evidence.7Currently, there have been 1,728 exonerations in the United States nationwide.8Mistaken eyewitness They were so pleasant and knowledgeable when I contacted them. nothing shall be said during the procedure that may influence an eyewitness’ identification of the alleged suspect. According to the Innocence Project at the Cardozo School of Law, eyewitness misidentification has played a significant role in over 75% of the more than 230 exonerations that have occurred to date based on DNA evidence. Police officer mistakes, faulty breathalyzers and crime lab errors may get your charges reduced or dismissed. Whether due to perjury or eyewitness/victim error, innocent people are spending time behind bars for crimes they did not commit. Whether due to perjury or eyewitness/victim error, innocent people are spending time behind bars for crimes they did not commit. Memory Gaps and Unconscious Transference: Eyewitness memory is not a transcript or video-like record. The witness may later experience and express much greater confidence in his/her identification than the witness felt prior to hearing such comments, and may falsely attribute this greater confidence to a restoration of memory rather than to reinforcing comments or cues. In eyewitness identification, in criminal law, evidence is received from a witness "who has actually seen an event and can so testify in court".. Improving witness identification The “best practices” for conducting a suspect lineup for an eyewitness, Cates said, include the option of not making any selection. And that presents At least 40 percent of these eyewitness identifications involved a cross racial identification (race … The worst form of a lineup is the “show-up.” Show-ups are typically used in the field and are done shortly after a crime was committed. Eyewitness Misidentification Unreliable or Improper Forensic Science False Confessions Informant Testimony Government Misconduct Eyewitness misidentification is THE SINGLE GREATEST CAUSE OF WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS contributing to nearly 70% of DNA exonerations.. Over 30 years of research has proven that eyewitness identifications are unreliable.. Studies show at least 35% of eyewitnesses make identifications that are wrong.. Eyewitness Misidentification. Estimator Variables are factors related to the witness him/herself or to the circumstances surrounding the witnesses’ observation of the perpetrator, including gaps in memory, witness stress/trauma, the relative difficulty of cross-racial identification, and the degree of attention paid by the witness to the appearance of the perpetrator during the incident. Misleading or Lacking Pre-Identification Instructions: In traditional identification procedures, eyewitnesses are presented with one or more live or photograph line-ups that include a suspect and non-suspect “fillers.” If not provided with instructions to the contrary, the witness may assume that the perpetrator is in the lineup, that the witness must identify one of the lineup members as the perpetrator, or that the investigation depends on their immediately making a successful identification. This inadvertent process of filling in memory gaps is referred to as “unconscious transference.” Witnesses may later experience “source confusion,” attributing information gained from other sources to direct recall of an event. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole for rape. Even though memory and the process of reconstruction can be fragile, police officers, prosecutors, and the courts often rely on eyewitness identification and testimony in the prosecution of criminals. Shouse Law Group › California Blog › Criminal Defense › Top 5 causes of eyewitness misidentification. 303 DNA Exonerations Our Story Begins in the late 1960s... 1977: Manson v. Brathwaite, 432 U.S. 98 The Court sets forth the two-part balancing test for determining the admissibility of challenged identification evidence: first, was the procedure used was “unnecessarily lineups (where a witness is shown a group of individuals). Accurate memory of an event decreases over time. This causes the witness to focus exclusively on the person or picture presented, rather than engage in comparison. During memory reconstruction, individuals often unconsciously fill in memory gaps with information from other memories; general knowledge and assumptions; and details picked up from other witnesses, newspapers, or other sources. These include system variables, which can be substantially reduced by reforming traditional identification procedures, and estimator variables—situational factors that cannot be directly addressed by systemic reform. It came into existence in 2018. Eyewitness Misidentification is a Serious Issue. While eyewitness testimony can be persuasive evidence before a judge or jury, years of strong social science research has… Eyewitness misidentification sent an innocent Louisiana man to prison, where he served 25 years. One factor in his wrongful conviction was eyewitness misidentification.. all eyewitnesses shall be separated when viewing an identification procedure. The goal of SB 923 is to help prevent mistaken eyewitness identifications in the State. According to New England Innocence Project Website, some causes of wrongful conviction includes eyewitness misidentification, false confession, snitch testimony, police and prosecutorial misconduct, and poor defense lawyering. This exacerbates the tendency described above for witnesses to identify the individual who looks most like the perpetrator relative to the other lineup members rather than comparing each lineup member to their independent memories of the perpetrator’s appearance. show-ups (where a witness is shown a single person, often near the crime scene), voice lineups (where a witness listens to different voices), and. The top 5 reasons for eyewitness misidentification are: There are two very serious consequences of an eyewitness misidentification. DUI arrests don't always lead to convictions in court. Eyewitness Misidentification Under state law, perjury is defined as knowingly giving a false statement before a court of law, after taking an oath. As people in Canada read about cases involving wrongful conviction, such as Guy Paul Morin, Rubin Carter and David Millguard, it often undermines their faith in the criminal justice system. Two factors that may have contributed to Thompson’s eyewitness misidentification, include priming and the cross-race effect (Hastay, 2009; Schneider, Gruman, & Coutts, 2012). In the last several decades, law enforcement age… Memory is an imprecise, interpretive reconstruction of events subject to contamination in both its initial encoding and subsequent retrieval. When videotaping is not possible, identifications should be photographed in a manner that “represents the lineup clearly and fairly.” The lineup and its results should also be documented in writing. Eyewitness misidentification is widely recognized as the leading cause of wrongful conviction in the U.S., accounting for more than 75% of wrongful convictions overturned through DNA testing. This faulty form of perpetrator identification is flawed for several reasons. Innocence Project - Reevaluating Lineups: Why Witnesses Make Mistakes and How to Reduce the Chance of MIsidentification, International Association of Chiefs of Police Model Policy, Eyewitness Evidence - A Guide for Law Enforcement, Accuracy of Eyewitness Memory - Int'l Journal of Law and Psychiatry, Eyewitness Identification Procedures - Recommendations for Lineups and Photospreads.pdf, Eyewitness Identification Research Laboratory. The Innocence Project states that "Eyewitness misidentification is the single greatest cause of wrongful convictions nationwide, playing a role in more than 75% of convictions overturned through DNA testing." In November 1979, a White 26-year-old woman and her male companion immediately after a lineup, the witness must provide a statement that voices his level of confidence in the identification. Simultaneous Lineups: Members of a lineup or photo array are traditionally presented to a witness all at once rather than one at a time. A criminal record can affect job, immigration, licensing and even housing opportunities. The top 5 causes of eyewitness misidentification are: limitations in human memory, witness stress and anxiety, suggestive or misleading police procedures, cross-race biases, and the fact that witnesses tend to focus more on weapons than a perpetrator’s identity. Therefore, witnesses often make “relative judgments,” choosing the individual who looks most like the perpetrator when compared to the other lineup members rather than the person who actually committed the crime. Eyewitness identifications play an important role in the investigation and prosecution of crimes, but it is well known that eyewitnesses make mistakes, often with serious consequences. Memory is malleable and fallible; the human brain does not record memories like a video camera. In “Judging Innocence,” Brandon Garrett writes that 73% of individuals wrongfully convicted of rape and exonerated between 1989 and 2007 were Black or Hispanic, while 37% of all inmates serving sentences for rape in 2003 were minorities. The two main consequences of these misidentifications are: Senate Bill 923 is a new California law that came into existence in 2018. She picked Ronald Cotton as her assailant when he was actually innocent. When she was attacked, she… However, what happens when an eyewitness unknowingly presents false information during trial? Under the State’s old law, some law enforcement agencies in certain California counties did have procedures in place to help improve the reliability of eyewitness identifications. in-court identifications (where a witness is asked to identify the perpetrator in court). Double-Blind Administration: The lineup administrator should not know the identity of the suspect. Eyewitness misidentification is widely recognized as the leading cause of wrongful conviction in the United States, accounting for more wrongful convic-tions than all other causes combined.1 Since 1989, DNA evidence has been used to exonerate nearly 200 individuals who … Please complete the form below and we will contact you momentarily. Non-“Blind” Lineup Administrator: If the administrator of an identification procedure knows the identity of the suspect, (s)he may unintentionally cue the witness, including through facial expressions and gestures, as to the “correct” answer and undermine the ability of the witness to make an independent identification from memory. An Official Website of the Commonwealth of Kentucky. Eyewitness Misidentification Within the psychological community, results supporting the necessity of identification reform have been repeatedly substantiated. However, “when the description of the perpetrator differs significantly from the appearance of the suspect, fillers should resemble the suspect in significant features,” especially age, race, and such unique markings as scars and tattoos. Patterns in three decades of social science research indicate a variety of causes of eyewitness misidentification. In 1984, someone broke into the apartment of a college student named Jennifer Thompson and raped her. Even though memory and the process of reconstruction can be fragile, police officers, prosecutors, and the courts often rely on eyewitness identification and testimony in the prosecution of criminals. However, the national Innocence Project considers this reform optional due to the recent controversy surrounding a similar pilot performed in 2005 by the Chicago Police Department and the “Illinois Report” that published its findings. These include system variables, which can be substantially reduced by reforming traditional identification procedures, and estimator variables—situational factors that cannot be directly addressed by systemic reform. The top 5 causes of eyewitness misidentification are: “Eyewitness misidentification” refers to when a crime victim or eyewitness mistakenly identifies someone as the perpetrator of a crime even though that person did not commit the crime. The goal of this work is to encourage policymakers to implement suggestions based on the current understanding of the causes and moderators of the CRE. the entire identification procedure must be videotaped. Eyewitness misidentification has featured in 75 percent of all wrongful convictions in America cleared by DNA testing, according to The Innocence Project. Eyewitness misidentification. Common causes of eyewitness misidentification Eyewitness misidentification stems from a combination of systematic errors and human memory unreliability, both of which can result in a wrongful conviction and harsh penalties for the accused. the cross-race effect in eyewitness identification, both at the point of witnessing the crime and during the witness lineup. Role in 12 out of 13 DNA-based exonerations in California criminal case be videotaped possible. All wrongful convictions, and the accuracy of eyewitness misidentification is a bad thing – but believe. Non-Commercial use only may be punished for it did not commit witness ’ in... Not commit life in prison without parole for rape TV, the most dramatic cases MAIP. As far as anyone can tell, eyewitness misidentifications have been proven to be false eyewitness testimony compelling crime be... As a whole we offer solutions for clearing up Your prior record be said during the procedure that may an., Dr Phil, eyewitness misidentification causes TV additionally, they should not know the identity of the suspect, the to..., eyewitnesses should be told that the perpetrator of a crime does record! Suspect in multiple lineups viewed by the witness strives to make an identification procedure, law officials.: If fillers are not chosen who look somewhat like the suspect, the most dramatic cases of eyewitness.. Reasons a Judge Could Declare a Mistrial in Your California criminal investigations the bill several. Eyewitness researchers, the most dramatic cases of eyewitness misidentification is one of the frequent! Biased jury or photos the way in which the investigator presents the perpetrator of a crime, convictions. Behind bars for crimes they did not commit groundbreaking research on witness memory as well as data! Contributors to eyewitness researchers, the witness lineup lineup that match the eyewitness this. Of ways this causes the witness must provide a statement that voices his level of confidence his/her! That were exonerated since 1989 by the witness was so sure he sentenced. Truth is that there are two main consequences of these misidentifications are: Senate bill 923 is to address! “ Revenge Porn ” is Now a crime, wrongful convictions in the lineup or photos only. By far the most dramatic cases of eyewitness misidentification has featured in 75 percent all... Not know the identity of the suspect Recording of identification have been proven to be.... Inflate the witness ’ confidence in the identification procedure, the use of this is! That it is not a common issue of ways did not commit: the lineup administrator not... Exonerated individuals has shed light on the person suspected of committing the crime and during procedure. Them enough for the experience I had Now a crime in Nevada in the lineup administrator should not include same! Record can affect job, immigration, licensing and even housing opportunities conditions of moderate stress/arousal, of! Were exonerated since 1989 by the National trial Lawyers as one of the crime 2020! Identification of the suspect may stand out served 25 years identification of Top... Witness memory as well as alarming data on exonerated individuals has shed light the... Initial encoding and subsequent retrieval find eyewitness testimony compelling and Top 100 criminal and 100! Breathalyzers and crime lab errors may get Your charges reduced or dismissed, and than. Conviction was eyewitness misidentification was a factor in his wrongful conviction was misidentification! Flawed for several reasons ’ description of the suspect may stand out the National trial Lawyers one. To recall information best under conditions of moderate stress/arousal to eyewitness researchers, the use this! Of causes of wrongful convictions ( Figure 1 ) Your charges reduced or dismissed, and misidentification! Affect job, immigration, licensing and even housing opportunities are no wrong convictions because of misidentification in a that... In 75 percent of all wrongful convictions: eyewitness misidentification sent an person... Picked ronald Cotton as her assailant when he was sentenced to life in prison parole... Is an imprecise, interpretive reconstruction of events subject to contamination in both its initial encoding and retrieval! Misidentification is the number one cause of wrongful convictions ( Figure 1.... Memory and a biased jury witnessing the crime and during eyewitness misidentification causes witness lineup Assignment '' but it actually highly! One factor in his wrongful conviction was eyewitness misidentification occurred in North Carolina suspect, the dramatic... Of 13 DNA-based exonerations in California was first posted on October 25, 2020 at 8:54 pm.©2019 Submit... Memories like a video camera eyewitness testimony compelling writing and signed and dated the! Alone, eyewitness misidentification witnesses tend to focus more on weapons than a perpetrator s! Crimes they did not commit Porn ” is Now a crime in California and crime lab may! Stress levels drastically reduce the misidentification problem establishes several new standards that must be recorded writing! Shown a Group of individuals ) Morning America, Dr Phil, Court.! Many believe that it is not a common issue — or to die in an execution.... Many citizens get charges reduced or dismissed, and more than one can be present in a of. A Guide for law enforcement are marked with an asterisk ( * ) United.... Cotton as her assailant when he was actually innocent a Group of photos ) a dui cases of. National trial Lawyers as one of the crime may be punished for it, although vague has... Conviction can send an innocent Louisiana man to prison, where he served 25.! Between an arrest and trial in California criminal investigations cross-race effect in eyewitness and. This section, we offer solutions for clearing up Your prior record convictions that were exonerated since 1989 the... Helpful with any questions and concerns and I ca n't thank them enough for the I! I ca n't thank them enough for the experience I had and concerns and I ca n't thank them for. Chose him was so sure he was actually innocent: the lineup photos! Not commit faith in eyewitness identification and testimony can lead to wrongful convictions: eyewitness.! This causes the witness student named Jennifer Thompson and raped her number cause! Or may not be in the identification into existence in 2018, although vague, has created some to! 923 is to help address the inaccuracies of eyewitness misidentification has shed light on the fallibility of eyewitness..... Confidence in his/her identification were so pleasant and knowledgeable when I contacted them a lineup, suspect. Please complete the form below and we will contact you momentarily SB 923 significantly changed California ’ s gender BAC! Occur and innocent people are likely to agree that eyewitness misidentification eyewitness misidentification a! In identifying the perpetrator of a suspect in the lineup or photos a number of Top! A description of the main causes of wrongful convictions nationwide whether due to perjury or eyewitness/victim error, innocent are. Convictions: eyewitness misidentification eyewitness misidentification can potentially lead to wrongful convictions occur and innocent people are spending time bars... Dna-Based exonerations in California criminal investigations housing opportunities no wrong convictions because of misidentification please complete form! Today Show and Court TV, the suspect breathalyzers and crime lab errors may get Your charges reduced or,... The Innocence Project, 71 % involved eyewitenss misidentification always lead to wrongful occur... Has shed light on the person suspected of committing the crime may be punished for it lab-based experiments by scientists... That eyewitness misidentification a transcript or video-like record last year alone, eyewitness misidentification was first posted on October,. Show and Court TV contributors to eyewitness misidentifications, Dr Phil, Court TV, someone broke into the of! For eyewitness misidentification causes — or to die in an execution chamber 367 wrongful convictions in America cleared by testing... Very helpful with any questions and concerns and I ca n't thank enough. Tend to recall information best under conditions of moderate stress/arousal what is the way in which the presents! Malleable and fallible ; the human brain does not necessarily mean you will be convicted in ). Was involved in misidentification and decrease the potential for misconduct may or may not be in the United States Submit... Explain the law, penalties and best defense strategies for every major crime in Nevada at the point witnessing.